Tag: LIFES50+

Testing tomorrow’s offshore wind technology

“Our main aim is to see the turbine out at sea and producing energy”, says Olav Weider, Managing Director at the Norwegian company Dr.techn.Olav Olsen AS. “Clean energy for the world. We believe that offshore wind has an important part to play in the green transition, and this is a milestone on the road towards that aim”, he says.

There are only a few floating wind turbines in the world at present. This autumn, Statoil installed the first wind farm consisting of floating turbines off the coast of Aberdeenshire in Scotland. Many more players are now entering the scene, all in the hope that technological advances will help to reduce costs and increase energy production.

“We believe that offshore wind has a big future”, says Leif Delp, a Project Director at Statoil. “We are now on the start line in terms of concept development”, he says. “Clearly we need to optimise our concepts and achieve better profitability, and this process is now under way. As more players enter the scene, perhaps coming up with new and exciting projects, we will definitely see dramatic reductions in the costs associated with power generation from floating wind turbines”, says Delp.

Long-lived concrete structures

Representatives of the industry and researchers met recently at SINTEF Ocean’s SeaLab facility where the final model tests of Dr.techn.Olav Olsens innovation were being carried out. The model was tested under normal current, wave and wind conditions, and was also subjected to extreme weather testing. The unique aspect of the company’s concept is that the turbine is of concrete construction. It is thus anticipated to have a long life with little need for extensive maintenance.

“We believe that the mass production of floating wind turbines will be easier than for fixed structures because the latter have to be specially tailored to the seabed conditions and water depths at the locations where they are installed”, says Weider. “Floating turbines can be much more adaptable in terms of their location”, he says.

Researchers at SINTEF are receiving an increasing number of requests from wind energy generating companies regarding the further development and testing of technologies for application in offshore energy production. The EU project LIFES50+ has enabled SINTEF’s team to develop a unique test method called “Real-Time Hybrid Model (ReaTHM®)”.

 

Model test tailored to offshore wind

“The wind turbine is exposed to physical waves and currents, and simulated wind loads – all in real time”, says Maxime Thys, a researcher at SINTEF Ocean. “The method provides considerable flexibility and reduces costs”, he says. “Costs are lower because we don’t have to design and build a rotor for the model. Flexibility is achieved because we can supply wind from various directions and can also simulate extreme conditions which it may be dangerous to implement using a physical model with a rotor”, he says.

The turbine tested at SINTEF was a 10 megawatt facility designed for installation in about 130 metres of water offshore Maine in the US.

“Statoil has prepared the ground with its own Hywind turbines”, says Weider. “A lot is happening in France, Japan and other places around the world. Offshore wind generation has been talked about for a long time, and is now becoming a significant market”, he says.

Phase one qualification performed

The overall concept rankings were based on  analysis of Levelised Cost of Energy (LCoE), Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) and Risk evaluation determined by the LIFES50+ Overall Evaluation tool named “Floating Offshore Wind Assessment Tool” (FOWAT).
Gruppebilde

 

The Overall Evaluation determined that Iberdrola’s TLP and Olav Olsen’s concrete semi-sub concepts should be selected for Phase II (Concept optimisation) of the project, where they will undergo further studies and optimization in order to verify that the concepts can accommodate a 10MW wind turbine in a cost effective way.

Experimental results from Hardware-in-the-Loop Model testing at SINTEF Ocean’s ocean basin in Trondheim and Politecnico di Milano’s wind tunnel in Milan will be used for further development and verification of the technologies using numerical simulation tools. The innovative concepts will be further developed, technically and economically, to reach a higher technology readiness level. The ultimate goals are to facilitate innovation, reduce risk, and reduce the LCOE, and the uncertainties associated with its estimation.

The evaluation process was subject to strict governing criteria to determine the outcomes and does not constitute any form of approval, verification or certification of the selected designs.

Phase One – Evaluation of the concepts

The four initial innovative concepts selected as part of the project are at TRL 4 and can accommodate wind turbines up to 5MW. These platforms are among the most advanced floating substructure concepts currently being developed in Europe.

Progress update

The Design basis (MS#1) provided the concept developers with the information required to upscale their floating platform concepts to support a 10MW wind turbine in three reference locations (Golfe de Fos, Gulf of Maine and West of Barra), representing different met-ocean conditions, and to identify the load cases and the wind turbine models for the design.

Bilde 1

In the second technical milestone (Concepts designs ready), the concept developers used information from MS#1 to upscale their concepts to accommodate a 10MW wind turbine. In this ongoing upscaling/optimization process, radically different choices regarding structural design, mooring design, wind turbine controller and marine operations are required.

In parallel, the Design practice review (MS#6) an overview of current design practice, procedures, methodology, guidelines and standards with a gap analysis was carried out.

Evaluation methodology ready (MS#3)has produced a LIFES50+ Overall Evaluation tool named “Floating Offshore Wind Assessment Tool (FOWAT)” to qualify the four concepts designs under an economic, environmental, risk and technical perspective. Of note is that floating wind energy is still at the early stages of its development and the associated experience is scarce. Therefore, the criteria and weighting factors that are applied in the evaluation tool are the agreed best estimates of the partners involved in the project and the tool development.

Phase 1 will be completed at a workshop in Barcelona from 8-10 of March 2017, where the Phase 1 qualification performed (MS#4) will present the evaluation of the four innovative concept designs and disclose the results. The overall concept rankings will be based on the scoring results obtained by the Levelised Cost of Energy (LCOE), Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) and Risk evaluation determined by FOWAT.

BildeillustrasjonNY_

Phase Two – Concept optimisation

Phase 2 of the project officially begins in April 2017, when the two selected concepts will undergo further studies in order to accommodate a 10MW wind turbine. The innovative concepts will be further developed, technically and economically, to reach a higher technology readiness level. Industrialisation, manufacturability and environmental impacts will also be considered with relevant guidelines/recommended practices produced.

Experimental results from scale model testing in both ocean basin and wind tunnels will be used to for further development and verification the technologies using numerical simulation tools. The ultimate goals are to facilitate innovation, reduce risk, and reduce the LCOE and the uncertainties associated with its estimation.

 

The third technical milestone: The Evaluation methodology ready in LIFES50+

The tool was developed to qualify the four concepts designs under an economic, environmental, risk and technical perspective, which enable the calculation of the following aspects to be considered in both Phase I and Phase II evaluation of the concept designs:

  • Economic assessment: Levelised Cost of Energy (LCoE) calculation expressed in €/MWh and included in the LCoE module of the Single Calculation Mode of the tool.
  • Environmental assessment: Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) analysis using three environmental indicators included in the LCA module.
  • Risk evaluation: Technology risk assessment included in Risk module.
  • Uncertainty assessment: Provides LCoE calculation considering an uncertainty range as per the inclusion of uncertainty ranges in some of the inputs used for the LCoE computation. This assessment is available in the LCoE module in the Evaluation Mode of the tool.
  • Ranking generator for concepts designs: Calculation of the final evaluation ranking of the designs using the results of LCoE, LCA and Risk assessment (multi-criteria analysis). This operation is executed in the Multi-Criteria module.
  • KPI information: Concept design technical description using key performance indicators and generation of a KPI report.

FOWAT – The overall evaluation tool structure

During the coming months the concept designer will use an agreed LCOE-LCA and KPI data collection questionnaire to feed the tool including iteration with the Evaluation Committee in order to improve / align their design for the Phase 1 selection. The overall concepts ranking will be based on the scoring results obtained by the LCOE, LCA and Risk evaluation given by FOWAT.

A workshop now planned in Barcelona for 6-8 of March 2017 will present the evaluation of the four designs and disclose the results; which two of the four concept have been selected for further studies in the project.

DESIGN | JJ DESIGN    CODE | KONSULENTEN

Button contacts

Contact us


Karoline Ski

Communication Manager


Mobile: +47 957 70 133

karoline.ski@sintef.no

Jan_Arthur_Norbeck

Jan Arthur Norbeck

Project Manager


Mobile: +47 951 10 424

JanArthur.Norbeck@marintek.sintef.no

Petter_Andreas_Berthelsen

Petter Andreas Berthelsen

Project Coordinator


Mobile: +47 952 22 139

PetterAndreas.Berthelsen@marintek.sintef.no